Skip to content
  • VisitHubers.com
  • HuberWinery.com
  • StarlightDistillery.com
  • PlantationHall.com
Starlight Distillery
  • Our Distillery
  • Whiskeys
    • Bourbons
    • Ryes
    • Other Whiskeys
    • Finishing
    • Flavored
    • Recipes
  • Other Spirits
    • Brandies
    • Gins
    • Rums
    • Vodka
    • Recipes
  • Single Barrel Program
  • Distiller’s Club
  • Where to Buy
  • Book a Tour
Back to Recipes

The Greatest Old Fashioned

Ingredients

  • 2 ounces Starlight Distillery Carl T. Bourbon Whiskey

  • 1/3 ounce Rich Brown Sugar Syrup (see recipe below)

  • 3-5 dashes Angostura bitters

  • 3 coffee beans

Instructions

In a mixing glass, add all ingredients and ice to fill the mixing glass three quarters of the way to the top. Stir for 10-15 seconds or until you feel the ice loosen up. Strain into rocks glass over a big cube and garnish with an expressed orange peel and a cherry (if you’re feeling extra special).

RICH BROWN SUGAR SYRUP
Put one cup of water in a pot on high heat and bring to a boil. Once boiling, add a quarter cup of organic brown sugar, a quarter cup of organic Demerara sugar, and a half cup of organic cane sugar. Lower temperature to medium heat and stir until dissolved. Once all dissolved, pull pot off heat and let cool. Bottle and refrigerate.

Share on Facebook
𝕏 Share on X
Share on Email
logo-mark

Explore More Recipes

The Forager’s Tonic

The Fix

Fog on the Farm

Join The Mailing List

Don’t miss a drop. Get exclusive behind-the-scenes access to our historic distillery, award-winning cocktail recipes, pre-sale access to limited-edition bottles, and more.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Starlight Distillery

19816 Huber Road,
Borden, IN 47106 | (812) 923-9463

please drink responsibly

To learn more about responsible consumption, please visit Responsibility.org.

  • Contact Us
  • Media & Trade
  • Employment
  • Privacy Policy
visit-indiana-logo

Copyright © 2026 Starlight Distillery. All Rights Reserved. Website by Louder Agency.

Are you over 21?